Skip to content
  • Policy and governance
  • Natural hazards
  • Modelling and projections

Deciding under uncertainty

What to do when the numbers stay wide: how to read a range, what a tonne costs, and why uncertainty is no argument for waiting.

9 stepsabout 21 min read

Uncertainty is the argument most used to defer action, and the most misunderstood. A wide range does not say that nothing is known: it says the bounds of the possible are known, and those bounds are often enough to decide on.

This path starts from the vocabulary of uncertainty, passes through what it is worth in scenarios and in pledges, then reaches the case where it stops being neutral. It assumes at least one discovery path has been read first.

  1. Step 1 of 9Termabout 2 min read

    Confidence level

    The codified vocabulary by which the IPCC states how solid a conclusion is and how probable a result.

    The prerequisite: knowing what 'likely' and 'high confidence' are worth before reading a synthesis full of them.

    Term
  2. Step 2 of 9Termabout 2 min read

    Climate sensitivity

    The global warming reached at equilibrium for a doubling of atmospheric CO₂ concentration relative to the pre-industrial era.

    The parameter whose range governs all the others. Narrowing it is the most important advance of the past twenty years.

    Term
  3. Step 3 of 9Briefabout 3 min read

    Reading climate scenarios

    What labels like SSP1-2.6 or SSP5-8.5 mean, how models are compared with one another, and why a scenario is not a forecast.

    Why a scenario is not a forecast, and what one may legitimately conclude from it.

    Brief
  4. Step 4 of 9Termabout 2 min read

    Nationally determined contribution

    A climate pledge a state submits of its own accord under the Paris Agreement, revisable every five years.

    The gap between what states promise and what their policies deliver, which is the real subject of the summits.

    Term
  5. Step 5 of 9Studyabout 2 min read

    Realization of Paris Agreement pledges may limit warming just below 2 °C

    Malte Alexander Meinshausen et al. · Nature · 2022

    What full delivery of announced pledges would give. To be compared with policies actually enacted.

    Study
  6. Step 6 of 9Briefabout 3 min read

    What climate costs

    How economists put a figure on damage, why their results diverge so widely, and what the social cost of carbon really covers.

    Putting a figure on damage, and the three normative choices every estimate conceals.

    Brief
  7. Step 7 of 9Termabout 2 min read

    Carbon price

    A cost attached to emitting a tonne of CO₂, through a tax or a market in allowances.

    The most debated instrument, and the distinction between the price one pays and the cost one causes.

    Term
  8. Step 8 of 9Briefabout 3 min read

    Tipping points

    What a threshold beyond which a system does not return actually is, which ones are documented, and why uncertainty about their position is not a reassuring argument.

    The case where uncertainty stops being symmetrical: a wide range means the threshold may be lower.

    Brief
  9. Step 9 of 9Studyabout 2 min read

    Exceeding 1.5°C global warming could trigger multiple climate tipping points

    David I. Armstrong McKay et al. · Science · 2022

    The reference survey. Read the ranges, not the central values — that is where the reasoning turns.

    Study

Path complete

You can carry on with the full directory or another path.